Key Largo's Finest Since Day One

Key Largo Deserves
Ice Cream This Good

Small batches. Real ingredients. Unapologetically homemade. Every scoop tells the story of a town where the ocean breeze meets the sweetest treat you'll ever taste.

50+ Unique Flavors
100% Homemade
Local Ingredients
Mr C's homemade ice cream in elegant presentation
🍨 Fresh Daily

Born on the Overseas Highway

What started as weekend experiments in a home kitchen has become Key Largo's most beloved ice cream destination. Mr C didn't just want to make ice cream — he wanted to make the kind of ice cream that reminds you why summer exists.

🥛

Real Cream, Real Fruit

No artificial shortcuts. We source fresh dairy and seasonal fruit to create flavors that taste like they came from nature, not a factory.

👨‍🍳

Small Batch Crafted

Every batch is churned by hand in limited quantities. This isn't mass production — it's passion poured into every gallon.

🏝️

Island Inspired

Key Largo's tropical spirit lives in our flavors. From coconut dreams to mango madness, each taste captures the essence of the Keys.

❤️

Community First

We're not just neighbors — we're family. Supporting local farmers, sponsoring events, and making this town sweeter, one scoop at a time.

Taste the Extraordinary

From classic favorites to wild creations that'll make you close your eyes and savor every bite. Our rotating menu means there's always something new to discover — and something familiar to love.

Classic vanilla bean ice cream
Classic

Madagascar Vanilla

Real vanilla beans swirled through cream so smooth it feels like a hug.

Rich dark chocolate ice cream
Indulgent

Midnight Chocolate

Double chocolate chunks in a fudge base so rich, it demands silence.

Fresh strawberry ice cream
Seasonal

Key Largo Strawberry

Local berries blended into a blush-pink dream that tastes like summer.

Tropical mango ice cream
Tropical

Mango Paradise

Tropical mangoes pureed to perfection — every spoonful is a vacation.

Premium pistachio ice cream
Premium

Roasted Pistachio

Salty-sweet pistachios folded through a velvety base. Pure elegance.

Coconut ice cream
Island Favorite

Coconut Dream

Shredded coconut and creamy coconut milk — the island never tasted so good.

And many more rotating flavors — stop in and discover today's specials!

Call to Ask

Come Say Hello

We're right on the Overseas Highway — easy to find, impossible to forget. Pull up, park, and let us make your day a little sweeter.

📍

Address

102800 Overseas Hwy
Key Largo, FL 33037

📞
🕐

Hours

Mon - Sun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Hours may vary — call ahead!

📞 Call (561) 504-6423
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website